In Whose Ruins
Power, Possession, and the Landscapes of American Empire
-
- $14.99
Publisher Description
In this “first-rate work of historical research and storytelling” (Kirkus Reviews, starred review), four sites of American history are revealed as places where truth was written over by oppressive fiction—with profound repercussions for politics past and present.
Popular narratives of American history conceal as much as they reveal, presenting a national identity based on harvesting treasures that lay in wait for European colonization. In Whose Ruins tells another story: winding through the US landscape, from Native American earthworks in West Virginia to the Manhattan Project in New Mexico, this history is a tour of sites that were mined for an empire’s power. Showing the hidden costs of ruthless economic growth—particularly to Indigenous people—this book illuminates the myth-making intimately tied to place. From the ground up, the project of settlement, expansion, and extraction became entwined with the spiritual values of those who hoped to gain from it. Every nation tells some stories and suppresses others, and In Whose Ruins illustrates the way American myths have overwritten Indigenous histories, binding us into an unsustainable future.
Historian Alicia Puglionesi? “makes a perfect guide through the strange myths, characters, and environments that best reflect the insidious exploitation inseparable from American dominion” (Chicago Review of Books). She illuminates the story of the Grave Creek Stone, “discovered” in an ancient Indigenous burial mound; oil wells drilled in the corner of western Pennsylvania once known as Petrolia; ancient petroglyphs that once adorned rock faces on the Susquehanna River, dynamited into pieces to make way for a hydroelectric dam; and the effects of the US nuclear program in the Southwest, which contaminated vast regions in the name of eternal wealth and security through atomic power, a promise that rang hollow for the surrounding Native, Hispanic, and white communities. It also inspired nationwide resistance, uniting diverse groups behind a different vision of the future—one not driven by greed and haunted by ruin.
This deeply researched work traces the roots of American fantasies and fears in a national tradition of selective forgetting. Connecting the power of myths with the extraction of power from the land itself reveals the truths that have been left out and is “a stimulating look at the erasure and endurance of Native American culture” (Publishers Weekly).
PUBLISHERS WEEKLY
Historian Puglionesi (Common Phantoms) examines how "Americans extracted literal power from the landscape and symbolic power from history" in this thought-provoking study of four geographical sites whose exploitation by white settlers helped create a mythology legitimizing their dominion over the country and its Indigenous inhabitants. In the early 19th century, Virginia's Grave Creek Mound archaeological site emerged not only as a tourist attraction but as a justification for Indian removal; the size and sophistication of the structure was supposedly beyond the capabilities of modern Native Americans and thus the work of a "lost race" whose rightful heirs were European settlers. Puglionesi also compares the decline of northwestern Pennsylvania's oil boomtowns in the 20th century to the displacement of Haudenosaunee tribes and details how, in the debate over the construction of a hydroelectric dam in northern Maryland in the 1920s, locals began to view ancient petroglyphs carved onto rocks above the Susquehanna River as "a warning about their own future." Puglionesi writes lucidly and packs the narrative full of intriguing minutiae, though the thrust of her argument occasionally gets lost. Still, this is a stimulating look at the erasure and endurance of Native American culture. Illus.
