With four children and a dilapidated farmhouse, Amish widow Honor King asks Seven Poplars's matchmaker to find her a secure and reliable new husband. Someone the opposite of her first love – who left her at the altar nine years ago, yet whom she's never been able to forget. Luke's back in town, and also looking for a new partner. For him, there's only one candidate to be his wife – the woman he let get away. But when Honor won't let him into her life, he works his way into her house. Hammer in hand, he'll fix her home…but it'll take more than brawn and nails to mend her heart.