Aspects of Good and Evil in "Harry Potter - The Prisoner of Azkaban‪"‬

In novels and fictional stories we often meet good and evil characters,
characters which fight each other. This fight between good and evil makes the
story really interesting and exciting because it hurries the action along. But often
the reader is not able to say which character really belongs to the good or the evil
ones. It is the ambiguity of the characters and their changes during the story that
grip the readers. This paper will have a look at one exemplary character and try to
solve the question whether it is good or evil. Besides, the thesis that animals and
creatures in The Prisoner of Azkaban cannot be categorized as clearly as the main
characters will be dealt with. In this way different aspects of the terms "good" and
"evil" shall be demonstrated. "Good" and "evil" represent a pair of opposites that is part of many stories and
of our whole life. Actions which are against virtues and values, which are
reprehensible and damnable, are generally seen as evil. Pleasure in destroying, in
lying, in betraying and in being cruel, in neglecting the rights of human beings,
these aspects are declared to be evil.1 They belong to actions and their
consequences which are caused by human beings, for example torturing innocent
people in a war. Due to St. Augustine, these are moral evils or deficiencies of
man's will. He thinks of the moral evil as the true evil because human beings have
free will and the choice to do good or evil. So it is their choice to commit evil
actions or not.2 [...]
1 See Rudolf Eisler, ed. Wörterbuch der philosophischen Begriffe 1, 4th ed. (Berlin: Mittler und
Sohn, 1927), p. 227.
2 See Ester S. Buchholz and Joshua K. Mandel, "Reaching for Virtue, Stumbling on Sin: Concepts
of Good and Evil in a Postmodern Era.", Journal of Religion and Health 39.2, (2000): p. 130.