"Because She's a Woman": Myth and Metafiction in Carol Shields's Unless (Critical Essay)
English Studies in Canada 2006, Dec, 32, 4
-
- CHF 3.00
-
- CHF 3.00
Descrizione dell’editore
IN THE CANADIAN POSTMODERN (1988), Linda Hutcheon observes the inherent conflicts between postmodernism and feminism. But Carol Shields succeeds brilliantly in combining her feminism and postmodernism in Unless (2002). Her last novel, Unless is her most explicitly feminist and her most intensely postmodernist text. She remarked, "I think I was the last feminist to wake up in the world: (1) She was braver about expressing her feminist beliefs in Unless because she did not think she would be alive to read the reviews. The narrator of Unless echoes these sentiments: "I am willing to blurt it all out, if only to myself. Blurting is a form of bravery. I'm just catching on to that fact. Arriving late, as always." (2) As Wendy Roy writes, "Unless is Shields' most explicitly feminist novel" (125). (3) Shields's feminism embraces egalitarian liberalism, however, not radical, militant feminism. For example, Shields and her Unless heroine both practise "bean-counting"--noting the exclusion of women from lists of the modern world's greatest thinkers and writers. (4) In her "Playwright's Note" to her play Thirteen Hands (1993), Shields asserts her commitment to the "redemption of women artists and activists" and her desire to reclaim these women, "to valorize those lives." Shields's daughter, writer Anne Giardini, confirms her mother's mission to address the "erasure" of these "invisible" women, "lost heroines," because this "obliteration is a tragedy" (12). Shields employs myth and metafiction to convey her feminism in Unless: she revises myth in a manner employed by feminist writers from H. D. to Atwood, and she employs metafictionality, fiction about the art of fiction, to critique women's place in a "withholding universe" (220). All Shields's novels are metafictional--beginning with her first novel, Small Ceremonies (1976), in which Judith Gill is writing a novel, through Sivann, in which critics cannibalize the poet Mary Swann, to The: Stone: Diaries, in which Daisy Goodwill Flett, who writes under the pen name Mrs Green Thumb, narrates her own autobiography-but Unless is her most explicitly metafictional novel, for her narrator uses fiction to reflect and resolve her real-life dilemma. While all Shields's heroines are writers, the heroine of Unless writes novels, like Shields herself: in contemplating her heroine's destiny, she revises her conception of the "happy ending" of marriage for women.