Matter of Reorganization of Elec. Mut. Liability Ins. Co., Ltd. (Bermuda‪)‬

Moot Question. Practice, Civil, Moot case. Evidence, Privileged communication. Attorney at Law, Attorney-client relationship. Waiver. LYNCH, J. This case arises from the approval by the Commissioner of Insurance (commissioner) of the application of Electric Mutual Liability Insurance Company (EMLICO) to reorganize and redomesticate to Bermuda. Allstate Insurance Company, Kemper Reinsurance Company, and other reinsurance companies sought judicial review of this decision. While these consolidated actions were pending in the Superior Court, counsel for Allstate received two documents from an anonymous source. According to the reinsurers, these documents support their claim that EMLICO deceived the commissioner by misrepresenting its financial condition at the time it sought to reorganize and to move to Bermuda.