The Examiner

PUBLISHERS WEEKLY 2024年7月29日

Combing through emails, essays, texts, and chatroom messages, a mysterious "examiner" uncovers the hidden motives of six graduate students enrolled in a multimedia art course at London's Royal Hastings University, in the convoluted latest epistolary mystery from Hallett (after The Mysterious Case of the Alperton Angels). With varying degrees of skill, the students—established artists Ludya and Alyson; gallery owner Jonathan; bored executive Cameron; art supply store owner Patrick; and emerging audio artist Jem—create elaborate art installations while forming friendships and rivalries that mask their true reasons for taking the class. As the communications wear on, it becomes clear that there's been a murder among the group, and that many of the students are concealing secret identities. With her colleague's help, class instructor Gela Nathaniel attempts to follow the clues to uncover the killer, but her efforts only propel the narrative to a tangled, unsatisfying conclusion. The initial novelty of the format collapses under the plot's increasingly intricate mix of climate activism, nuclear threats, and latent Cold War intrigue. This is likely to leave readers lost.