People State New York v. Felix Rodriguez

This appeal centers on the "confirmatory identification" exception to the notice and hearing requirements of the Criminal Procedure Law for suggestive pretrial identification procedures. We conclude that, where a citizen eyewitness claimed to have seen the defendant numerous times in a store, it was error to deny defendants Wade hearing motions summarily, because the witness assertion did not establish such familiarity with defendant that the danger of police suggestiveness was eliminated as a matter of law.