The Ethical Lacunae in Friedman's Concept of the Manager (Milton Friedman) (Critical Essay) The Ethical Lacunae in Friedman's Concept of the Manager (Milton Friedman) (Critical Essay)

The Ethical Lacunae in Friedman's Concept of the Manager (Milton Friedman) (Critical Essay‪)‬

Journal of Markets & Morality 2008, Fall, 11, 2

    • 14,99 lei
    • 14,99 lei

Publisher Description

Milton Friedman promotes two doctrines in Capitalism and Freedom. The first is in regard to the proper role and use of corporate profits. The second is in regard to the moral foundations required for a stable society. Unfortunately, Friedman's doctrine on profit is often applied without reference to his second doctrine on ethics (James and Rassekh 2000). In a similar way, Adam Smith's economic injunctions in The Wealth of Nations are often misunderstood because the moral underpinnings for them in The Theory of Moral Sentiments are ignored. In both cases, an understanding of economic processes is weakened (Evensky 2005; Young 1997). This article analyzes the interconnections between the instrumental role of profits and the intrinsic role of morals in Friedman's model, using for its analytical framework the moral sentiments theory of Adam Smith. The article also examines whether Friedman's profit-maximization goal adequately motivates managerial activity. The key problem with Friedman's mandate on profits is that it gives rise to a fundamental inconsistency: On one level, Friedman utilizes a largely consequentialist ethic to explain how markets and economic actors behave, yet he simultaneously relies upon managers to uphold an internal ethic based on duty and virtue. The psychological dissonance created may produce both hypocrisy and inefficiency. A subtler version of Friedman's injunction on profits and the manager is warranted, in which virtue ethics might provide a meaningful approach to motivation within the firm.

GENRE
Business & Personal Finance
RELEASED
2008
22 September
LANGUAGE
EN
English
LENGTH
27
Pages
PUBLISHER
Acton Institute
SIZE
278.6
KB
The Influence of Kant on Christian Theology: A Debate About Human Dignity and Christian Personalism: A Response to Derek S. Jeffreys (Controversy) (Immanuel Kant) (Essay) The Influence of Kant on Christian Theology: A Debate About Human Dignity and Christian Personalism: A Response to Derek S. Jeffreys (Controversy) (Immanuel Kant) (Essay)
2004
Milton Friedman on Income Inequality (Critical Essay) Milton Friedman on Income Inequality (Critical Essay)
2008
Dubitatio 21: Are All Kinds of Monopoly Unjust?(On Buying and Selling (1605)) (Excerpt) Dubitatio 21: Are All Kinds of Monopoly Unjust?(On Buying and Selling (1605)) (Excerpt)
2007
Argument 402: if an Employee Who Was Taking Money in Gold Coins to Pay Some Debts, Or to Make Some Purchases, Took Advantage on the Way of an Opportunity Offered to Exchange Those Coins for a Better Price, Could That Employee Appropriate for Himself the Extra Charge Obtained in This Manner?(Treatise on Money) (Excerpt) Argument 402: if an Employee Who Was Taking Money in Gold Coins to Pay Some Debts, Or to Make Some Purchases, Took Advantage on the Way of an Opportunity Offered to Exchange Those Coins for a Better Price, Could That Employee Appropriate for Himself the Extra Charge Obtained in This Manner?(Treatise on Money) (Excerpt)
2005
Argument 398: on Exchange in a Strict Sense and Its Types. Is the Exchange Dealer's Activity Licit?(Treatise on Money) (Excerpt) Argument 398: on Exchange in a Strict Sense and Its Types. Is the Exchange Dealer's Activity Licit?(Treatise on Money) (Excerpt)
2005
The Judeo-Christian Foundation of Human Dignity, Personal Liberty, And the Concept of the Person (Critical Essay) The Judeo-Christian Foundation of Human Dignity, Personal Liberty, And the Concept of the Person (Critical Essay)
1998