The Identity Trap: A Story of Ideas and Power in Our Time (Unabridged)
-
-
4.3 • 22 Ratings
-
-
- $16.99
Publisher Description
Named a Best Book of the Year by The Economist, Financial Times, Inc., Prospect Magazine, and The Conversation
“The most comprehensive and reasonable story of this shift that has yet been attempted . . . Mounk has told the story of the Great Awokening better than any other writer who has attempted to make sense of it.” —The Washington Post
“An intellectual tour de force about the origins of identity politics and the threat it presents to genuine, honest, old-fashioned liberalism.” —Bret Stephens, The New York Times
“Among the most insightful and important books written in the last decade on American democracy and its current torments, because it also shows us a way out of the trap.” —Jonathan Haidt, author of The Righteous Mind, and coauthor of The Coddling of the American Mind
“Outstanding.” —David Brooks, The New York Times
A fascinating account of the origins of “wokeness”—and a trenchant explanation for why the noble goals of identity politics are doomed to fail
For much of history, societies have violently oppressed ethnic, religious, and sexual minorities. It is no surprise that many came to believe that members of marginalized groups need to take pride in their identity to resist injustice. But over the past decades, a healthy appreciation for the culture and heritage of minority groups transformed into a counterproductive obsession with group identity. This new ideology denies that members of different groups can truly understand each other and insists that the way governments treat their citizens should depend on the color of their skin.
This, Yascha Mounk argues, is the identity trap. Those who battle for these ideas are often full of good intentions. But they ultimately stand in the way of the genuine equality we desperately need. Mounk built his acclaimed scholarly career on being one of the first to warn of the risks that right-wing populists pose to American democracy, a danger that now remains as serious as ever. But far from being mortal enemies, the identitarian left and the populist right actually reinforce each other; to vanquish one, he shows here, it is necessary to oppose both.
In The Identity Trap, Mounk provides the most ambitious and comprehensive account to date of the origins, consequences, and limitations of “wokeness.” He shows how postmodernism, postcolonialism, and critical race theory conquered many college campuses. He lays out how these ideas gained tremendous influence in business, media, and government, and he makes a nuanced philosophical case for why these ideas are so counterproductive—and why universal, humanist values can best serve the vital goal of true equality. The Identity Trap provides truth and clarity where they are needed most.
Customer Reviews
Well-Written Overview of a Common Opinion
For those that have been following this issue for awhile will probably not learn too much from this. And I would not call it a work of serious scholarship, per se. However, it is an honest overview of the major ideas at play and of the liberal alternative to identity synthesis. In other words, a nice narrative reference that sort if lets you know where to start if you want to dig deeper into a given area (for example, critical race theory doesn’t begin AND end with Dereck Bell + Kimberle Crenshaw, but now you know where to start if you want to learn more).
As far as accuracy: I could quibble with some points - for example, he cites survey data suggesting that black and latino people are actually less enamored with identity (which is true), but doesn’t consider whether that could be explained by their relative lack of access to education about our history, policies, and so on, which are endlessly depressing as far as treatment of non-whites goes. But ultimately it seems like these omissions are done for brevity and for getting at larger points that are otherwise decently supported, so they don’t bother me too much.
Lastly, I greatly appreciated that he dedicated some time at the end of the book to warn against being reactionary (his word), which seems like a responsible thing to do given the readership for these kinds of books includes people with the kind of far-right persuasions Mounk has criticized in his previous books (and occasionally, throughout this one).
Overall, I recommend.
An honest critique
It was breath of fresh air to read a critique of “the identity synthesis” without it veering into the cultural Marxism conspiracy theory or some other unfounded garbage.