Every Christmas for the past eleven years, Merry Anne Martinnelli has wished for the chance to have a "do-over" and accept Josh Johnson's marriage proposal. She doesn't know Josh wishes for a second chance, too. Or that he has returned to Tassanoxie in the hopes of mending the rift.
Josh conspires with Merry Anne's brother to set up a meeting with her, unaware his house has become the target of a burglary. When the unsuspecting Merry Anne tries to deliver a pizza, two burglars answer the door, drag her in the house, and lock her in a kitchen pantry with the unconscious homeowner.
Suddenly, Merry Anne has the future she's dreamed about??"the house, the dog, and the 2.5 children??"within her grasp. Will she be able to forgive Josh for breaking her heart, not once, but twice? Will she get her Christmas "do-over" wish?