Grace had finally gotten used to her new afterlife as a "Made" - a Reaper who used to be human. When Made Reapers and souls begin disappearing, however, Grace and her mentor Tully suspect demons. Grace's worst fears are confirmed when her sister's soul is threatened.
She'll have to break every rule in the Reaper book to save them, including using a little magic to become temporarily human. With the help of Tully and her witchy friend Tessa, Grace goes undercover on a college campus to save the fates of kidnapped souls. What she didn't count on was the boy who makes her laugh like no other, who makes her feel alive again and question her existence. With her own soul in peril, Grace realizes that demons aren't working alone. Betrayal and distrust runs deep and Grace discovers that sometimes even Reapers are prone to humanity.