Selena Lehman inherits a house from her estranged Amish grandfather and visits to take a look. When she sees it's not being cared for, she confronts the caretaker, John Yoder.
The condition of the house falls to a low priority when she learns her grandfather died in prison after admitting to murder. Convinced there's more to this story, she finds her way to Ettie Smith's doorstep.
Soon, Selena finds everything she knows to be true about her life is a lie.
Can Ettie help Selena unravel the secrets and clear her grandfather's name before her straight-laced lawyer fiance discovers her grandfather was a common criminal?