Amish girl Annie is determined to win the handsome Jessie Yoder's heart.
The only thing standing in Annie's way is Liz, a long term house guest of Annie's family.
Annie is downcast as Jessie cannot take his eyes off Liz.
Liz is everything that Annie is not.
While Annie wears her plain Amish clothes and no makeup, Liz wears the latest English fashions and is never seen without makeup or high heels.
Things go from bad to worse when Liz appears to be returning Jessie's attentions.
How can Annie possibly compete with the beautiful Liz to win Jessie's heart while staying true to her Amish values?