Cassidy Monroe spends most of her time finding love for her clients as co-owner of Match Made in Heaven, a matchmaking company located in Seattle, Washington. Cassidy loves her job and rarely thinks about finding love herself, that is until sexy ex-pitcher for the Seattle Sharks baseball team, Noah Worth, walks through her office doors. The only problem is that Noah isn't exactly looking for love either. He is simply looking for "arm candy" or a fake girlfriend to take to fancy events. Unable to find a client willing to satisfy Noah's needs, Cassidy winds up taking one for the team. Can this awkward matchmaker and sexy billionaire manage to honor their "no emotions" contract, or will they hit a home run with love?