Community. Community.

Community‪.‬

English Studies in Canada 2004, Dec, 30, 4

    • $5.99
    • $5.99

Publisher Description

Raymond Williams's entry for "Community" in Keywords (75-6) is straightforward enough, though it is characteristically succinct, comprehensive, and subtle. He gives a brief history of the etymology of the word and of the different meanings the word has had since it entered the English language in the fourteenth century. He also sets "community" against French and German words, commune and Gemeinde. He refers to Tonnies' influential contrast (1887) between Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft: community, on the one hand, and more impersonal organization or corporation, on the other. Though Williams distinguishes five senses of "community." the essence of his definition is expressed in the following phrases: "a sense of common identity and characteristics," "the body of direct relationships" as opposed to "the organized establishment of realm or state." A community is "relatively small," with a "sense of immediacy or locality:' Williams stresses the affective aspect of the word and its performative power: "Community can be the warmly persuasive word to describe an existing set of relationships, or the warmly persuasive word to describe an alternative set of relationships (76)." What Williams meant by "community" is developed more circumstantially in The Country and the City, especially in chapters to, m, and 18 of that book: "Enclosures, Commons and Communities," "Knowable Communities," and "Wessex and the Border." The last two me on George Eliot and Thomas Hardy, respectively. Williams does not wholly admire George Eliot, or Jane Austen, whereas Hardy gets his more or less complete approval. What is the difference? "Jane Austen," says Williams, "had been prying and analytic, but into a limited group of people in their relations with each other" (168). Eliot, according to Williams, was, like Jane Austen before her, ore or less limited in her comprehension to members of the gentry. The latter formed her "knowable community." She did not really understand the common people, rural farmers, laborers, servants, and tradesmen. They and their community were "unknowable" to her. In Williams's view, Eliot projected her own inner life into lower class people in her novels and was consistently condescending to them. "George Eliot" says Williams, "gives her own consciousness, often disguised as a personal dialect, to the characters with whom she does really feel; but the strain of the impersonation usually evident-in Adam, Daniel, Maggie, or Felix Holt" (169). The latter judgment, by the way, seems questionable. Hetty Sorrel, for example, in Adam Bede, seems to me a plausible characterization of someone to a considerable degree unlike George Eliot herself Like Williams, I come from a rural background, though at the distance of an extra generation, so, like Williams, I too can speak from direct experience about this. Can it be that there is a trace of misogyny in Williams's putdown of Austen and Eliot, in favor of male novelists like Hardy and Lawrence? "Prying and analytic" is a really nasty epithet, and what worse can one say of a supposedly objective realist novelist than that all her protagonists are versions of herself?

GENRE
Professional & Technical
RELEASED
2004
December 1
LANGUAGE
EN
English
LENGTH
10
Pages
PUBLISHER
Association of Canadian College and University Teachers of English
SELLER
The Gale Group, Inc., a Delaware corporation and an affiliate of Cengage Learning, Inc.
SIZE
164.1
KB
Beyond Boundaries Beyond Boundaries
2020
Radical Research Radical Research
2007
Helen Vendler. Poets Thinking: Pope, Whitman, Dickenson, Yeats (Book Review) Helen Vendler. Poets Thinking: Pope, Whitman, Dickenson, Yeats (Book Review)
2006
The Importance of Hawaiian Language Sources for Understanding the Hawaiian Past (Critical Essay) The Importance of Hawaiian Language Sources for Understanding the Hawaiian Past (Critical Essay)
2004
Keywords: Raymond Williams and Others (Critical Essay) Keywords: Raymond Williams and Others (Critical Essay)
2004
David Schmid. Natural Born Celebrities: Serial Killers in American Culture (Book Review) David Schmid. Natural Born Celebrities: Serial Killers in American Culture (Book Review)
2008
Skin Aesthetics As Incarnation: Gilles Deleuze's Diagram of Francis Bacon (Report) Skin Aesthetics As Incarnation: Gilles Deleuze's Diagram of Francis Bacon (Report)
2008
Margaret Atwood's Alias Grace and the Construction of a Trial Narrative (Critical Essay) Margaret Atwood's Alias Grace and the Construction of a Trial Narrative (Critical Essay)
2006