Amish man, Levi Fuller, is the second oldest son. After his brother's recent marriage, he knows his family expects him to marry Lucy, the girlfriend he's had for several months. Levi doesn't mind, he's in love with Lucy, but ever since his older brother married she's been acting strange. When Levi confronts her, she tells him she doesn't approve of his older brother's choice in a wife.
As Levi is trying to defend his new sister-in-law, a rift develops between them. The rift grows wider when a friend of Lucy's returns from rumspringa and encourages Lucy to stay away from Levi. But does Lucy's friend have an ulterior motive? Levi knows his mother does not want Lucy as a potential daughter-in-law. Could his mother see things that he didn't? Will Levi sort out his differences with Lucy, or will he be swayed by the young woman who is throwing herself at him?