The Real Estate Secondaries Investor
A Practitioner's Guide to Pricing an Appraisal, LP Portfolios and Real Estate Continuation Vehicles
-
- $12.99
-
- $12.99
Publisher Description
An interest in a European real estate fund is reported at 38.5 million and offered at 82 per cent of that number. The memo calls it an 18 per cent discount to net asset value, and the committee spends an hour on whether 18 is enough.
That discussion rests on a mistake. The number being discounted is not a value. It is an appraisal — anchored on the previous appraisal, moved only as far as the evidence supported, and delivered weeks after the evidence itself. Discounting it by 18 per cent does not buy 18 per cent below value.
Remove the smoothing from the reported series and the discount is 14.42 per cent. Add the unfunded commitment, which is funded at par and bought at no discount at all, and it is 13.01. Deduct the management fees the interest still owes to the end of the fund's life and it is 9.18. The headline is roughly twice the truth, and none of the three deductions is a market view: each is computed from documents already in the data room.
This book prices one interest completely, and it prices it twice. Once by unsmoothing the appraisal series, which is one line of arithmetic and yields a threshold rather than an opinion — below an appraiser absorbing about 13 per cent of new information a quarter, an 18 per cent discount buys nothing. And once by rebuilding the net asset value from the bottom, out of six rent lines, six exit yields and six capital expenditure lines. The two methods share no inputs and land 0.87 per cent apart, which is the strongest thing a buyer can bring to a committee that has never seen the buildings.
It then prices what nobody puts a number on. What a continuation vehicle's fee and carried interest cost a rolling investor, expressed as annual return rather than as governance. What discount justifies selling units today instead of waiting in an open-ended fund's redemption queue. What a seller's insistence on an all-or-nothing portfolio costs the seller. And what twenty-five basis points on the exit yields is worth — more, it turns out, than the entire smoothing argument, which sets the order in which to spend your time.
It is written for secondaries buyers and advisers, for limited partners deciding whether to sell or roll, for fund managers running a continuation process, and for anybody who has to defend a percentage of net asset value to an investment committee.
Five Excel workbooks accompany the book, with no sign-up. Twenty-eight figures are checked and all twenty-eight reproduce, and the fifth is the seventy-two-question checklist of Appendix A with room to answer it — with a status column that marks any answer lacking a source document as unsourced.
About this edition: the text of this book was generated with AI (Claude) and published by the author.