James Lewis Biddle v. William H. Haddix

"In a personal injury action, issues involving primary negligence on the part of the defendants, contributory negligence on the part of the plaintiff, due care and proximate cause are proper for determination by the jury when the evidence pertaining to such issues is conflicting, involving credibility of witnesses, or where the evidence, though undisputed or without conflict, is such that reasonable men may properly draw different Conclusions from it." Point 1 Syllabus, Poe v. Pittman, 150 W.Va. 179.