With his two older brothers recently married, Joshua Fuller has quickly become the most popular bachelor in the Amish community. He has not one, not two, but three girls who have told him that they would like to become his wife. The only thing is, he is not interested in any of them. The only girl who has caught his eye is the only one who pays him no attention. What will he do when he finds out she has been helping one of the other girls in a plot to gain his attention? Is she really the girl for him, or is there someone else he has overlooked?