Kristol Vs. Oakeshott. Kristol Vs. Oakeshott.

Kristol Vs. Oakeshott‪.‬

Modern Age 2011, Wntr-Spring, 53, 1-2

    • $5.99
    • $5.99

Publisher Description

In 1956, the English philosopher Michael Oakeshott published "On Being Conservative," (1) a statement of "the conservative disposition" as he conceived it. Although largely well received, Oakeshott's conception of conservatism was not without its critics. Among their number was the American intellectual and self-avowed "conservative" Irving Kristol, who, while admitting to "loving every line" of Oakeshott's essay, to admiring it "immensely," claimed that its "irredeemably secular" character repelled him. (2) Oakeshott's vision of conservatism, he charged, is insufficiently religious in two respects. First, Kristol imputes to it an obsession with the present that can't but be anathema to Jewish and Christian sensibilities by reason of its concomitant neglect of the past and the future. Jews and Christians can't but find "it is impossible. . . to have the kinds of attitudes toward the past and the future that Oakeshott's conservative disposition celebrates," for their traditions "link us to the past and to the future with an intensity lacking in Oakeshott's vision." (3) Second, the centrality of place Oakeshott allegedly assigns to the present not only renders his vision unpalatable to traditional religion but violates as well the spirit of the civic religion of America. Americans, Kristol explains, have an "emphatic and explicit" commitment to their past that is "ideological" (4); theirs is an "ideological patriotism" that is rooted in the United States' identity as "a 'creedal' nation," a nation to which anyone can belong irrespective of "ethnicity, or blood ties of any kind, or lineage, or length of residence even." The uniquely "ideological" character of American patriotism and the foundational "creed" from which it springs, Kristol contends, are both "suffused with a kind of religious sensibility" that constitutes what can legitimately be called a "civic religion." (5) Although there are indeed "tensions" between "American religiosity and the more secular 'civic religion,'" "both are, in general, future-oriented and 'progressive' in their political vision." (6)

GENRE
Professional & Technical
RELEASED
2011
January 1
LANGUAGE
EN
English
LENGTH
20
Pages
PUBLISHER
Intercollegiate Studies Institute Inc.
SELLER
The Gale Group, Inc., a Delaware corporation and an affiliate of Cengage Learning, Inc.
SIZE
173.8
KB
The Place of Michael Oakeshott in Contemporary Western and Non-Western Thought The Place of Michael Oakeshott in Contemporary Western and Non-Western Thought
2017
James Mill James Mill
2017
Virtue and the Making of Modern Liberalism Virtue and the Making of Modern Liberalism
2000
Value, Conflict, and Order Value, Conflict, and Order
2020
Modern Theories of Politics Modern Theories of Politics
2015
General Will In Political Philosophy General Will In Political Philosophy
2013
Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged: From Romantic Fallacy to Holocaustic Imagination. Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged: From Romantic Fallacy to Holocaustic Imagination.
2004
The Great Gatsby. (An Article from Modern Age 2007, Spring, Vol. 49, (2) The Great Gatsby. (An Article from Modern Age 2007, Spring, Vol. 49, (2)
2007
Ortega Y Gasset's "Revolt" and the Problem of Mass Rule (Critical Essay) Ortega Y Gasset's "Revolt" and the Problem of Mass Rule (Critical Essay)
2004
Honesty in the Face of Delusion (Atheist Delusions: The Christian Revolution and Its Fashionable Enemies) (Book Review) Honesty in the Face of Delusion (Atheist Delusions: The Christian Revolution and Its Fashionable Enemies) (Book Review)
2010
The Essential Guardini (Romano Guardini's Works) The Essential Guardini (Romano Guardini's Works)
2005
Reading the Iliad in the Light of Eternity ('on the Iliad', 'the Iliad, Or the Poem of Force') Reading the Iliad in the Light of Eternity ('on the Iliad', 'the Iliad, Or the Poem of Force')
2006