Martial Musings

Good and Bad

This book is a fascinating look at Robert Smith’s extensive experiences in the martial art world, but disturbing in it’s increasing criticism of other practitioners and methods as the book progresses. His earlier books and articles are well-organized, tactful, and superbly written. I recommend any of those earlier books without reservation, and you should read any of those before attempting to read Musings. The best parts of this book are similarly his personal experiences in boxing, judo, and Chinese martial arts; which have tons of historical detail and personal anecdotes. He has met many of the most well-known and proficient twentieth century practitioners, and was trained by and sparred with many. He was one of the leaders in bringing Asian martial arts to America. His overall philosophy is that martial arts are at their best as a vehicle for personal development best disseminated by good teachers in the social setting of local studios. Musings is more memoir and autobiography than history or analysis. He has strong opinions, not only about martial schools and practitioners, but about many areas not related to the martial arts, including politics. Unfortunately he does not hold back. I do not think the book is for beginners- you have to be selective in enjoying the more useful parts, while practicing dispassion and discipline in blocking out the increasing criticism in the latter parts of the book. There is something in this book to offend almost anyone, which unfortunately distracts from the otherwise excellent material he offers. With that stipulation, I do recommend it for serious students of judo and the Chinese martial arts.