Sincere Hypocrisy and the Authorial Persona in the Letters of Heloise. Sincere Hypocrisy and the Authorial Persona in the Letters of Heloise.

Sincere Hypocrisy and the Authorial Persona in the Letters of Heloise‪.‬

Romance Notes, 2005, Spring, 45, 3

    • $5.99
    • $5.99

Publisher Description

READING the letters of Heloise might be compared to coming face to face with a basilisk. The text, like that mythical beast, both fascinates and paralyzes us, holds our gaze even as it resists our attempts to gain the upper hand. (1) That mixture of enthrallment and frustration, tempered with the crippling inability to attain a concrete meaning, is probably familiar to many readers of this famous 12th century French intellectual's correspondence with her husband and former teacher, Peter Abelard. It is also, at least to some extent, the result of a specific rhetorical strategy on Heloise's part. As Peggy Kamuf has demonstrated, Heloise's letters stage a "breakdown of [the] structure of opposition" on which both language and logic are based (44). Heloise creates extended metaphors and builds arguments around opposing pairs of concepts, only to destabilize or destroy the putative differences on which these oppositions are based. Self-fulfillment and self-destruction, marriage and concubinage, chastity and licentiousness, religious devotion and blasphemy, are just a few of the opposing pairs that, as Kamuf shows, Heloise blurs, "displaces" or "reverses" in her letters (13). Kamuf's insight is particularly apt because it reminds us that logic--the medieval "art of speaking truly" is structured around a cluster of basic oppositions. (2) As the prize pupil of the most important logician of her day, Heloise would have been acutely aware that oppositions are the building blocks of reason, and indeed of meaning. This article will examine Heloise's use of what is for her a particularly crucial opposition, that between hypocrisy and sincerity. (3) In her letters, Heloise repeatedly examines her own sincerity and hypocrisy, ultimately refusing to decide between the two and embracing the identity of the "sincere hypocrite." Heloise's dismantling of the sincerityhypocrisy pair is an example of the rhetorical strategy that Kamuf has described, but I believe its particular interest lies in the light that it can shed on the construction of Heloise's authorial persona. By simultaneously calling attention to her own sincerity and casting it into doubt, Heloise also privileges and interrogates the link between self and words. Her discourse of sincere hypocrisy draws readers towards an imagined author even as it suggests that this seductive figure may be unreliable and illusory. In this case, the basilisk facing readers of Heloise's letters turns out to be the paradoxical authorial persona of Heloise herself.

GENRE
Professional & Technical
RELEASED
2005
March 22
LANGUAGE
EN
English
LENGTH
19
Pages
PUBLISHER
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Department of Romance Languages
SELLER
The Gale Group, Inc., a Delaware corporation and an affiliate of Cengage Learning, Inc.
SIZE
195.8
KB

More Books Like This

The Presence of Persons The Presence of Persons
2016
The Printed Voice of Victorian Poetry The Printed Voice of Victorian Poetry
2018
5 Steps to a 5: 500 AP English Literature Questions to Know by Test Day, Second Edition 5 Steps to a 5: 500 AP English Literature Questions to Know by Test Day, Second Edition
2018
Chaucer: The Canterbury Tales Chaucer: The Canterbury Tales
1998
God and Self in the Confessional Novel God and Self in the Confessional Novel
2018
A Theology Of Reading A Theology Of Reading
2018

More Books by Romance Notes

?Victoria Contra Corin Tellado?: La Novela Rosa Revolucionaria Cubana Y La Ficcion En Mujeres. ?Victoria Contra Corin Tellado?: La Novela Rosa Revolucionaria Cubana Y La Ficcion En Mujeres.
2009
Jerga Y Juerga: La Fusion De Elementos Carnavalescos En La Noche Es Virgen De Jaime Bayly. Jerga Y Juerga: La Fusion De Elementos Carnavalescos En La Noche Es Virgen De Jaime Bayly.
2006
El Laberinto Del Fauno: Una Alegoria Para La Espana Democratica. El Laberinto Del Fauno: Una Alegoria Para La Espana Democratica.
2009
In and out of the Mainstream: Dominican-American Identity in Junot Diaz's How to Date a Browngirl, Blackgirl, Whitegirl, Or Halfie. In and out of the Mainstream: Dominican-American Identity in Junot Diaz's How to Date a Browngirl, Blackgirl, Whitegirl, Or Halfie.
2009
Confusion in the Service of Clarity: The Circus in Patrick Modiano's Un Cirque Passe. Confusion in the Service of Clarity: The Circus in Patrick Modiano's Un Cirque Passe.
2005
Mother-Daughter Relationship in Laura Esquivel's Como Agua Para Chocolate. Mother-Daughter Relationship in Laura Esquivel's Como Agua Para Chocolate.
2009