The Fallacy of Scientific Truth: Why Science Succeeds Despite Ultimate Ignorance The Fallacy of Scientific Truth: Why Science Succeeds Despite Ultimate Ignorance

The Fallacy of Scientific Truth: Why Science Succeeds Despite Ultimate Ignorance

Publisher Description

Scientific knowledge is vastly and overwhelmingly humanity's greatest achievement. Furthermore, if humanity is to survive, either on this planet or perhaps eventually elsewhere in the universe, it will do so only because of scientific knowledge.
Nevertheless, scientific knowledge is not truth.
To assert any scientific knowledge to be true is to assert that beyond doubt we know the phenomena at issue occur for exactly and only the reason(s) specified by the scientific knowledge, and we similarly know they do so occur and will so occur at any time and at any place in the universe where the causal reason(s) obtain.
To claim scientific knowledge does not reach this truth standard is not new. Philosophers of science generally hold scientific knowledge always to be tentative and subject to refinement and/or replacement if and when new evidence is found. Therefore, scientists never use the word "truth" to describe their conclusions. Unfortunately, however, while theoretical scientists are too circumspect to call scientific conclusions true, they frequently treat them as if they were true. The most conspicuous examples of this are those cases, exceedingly common, wherein a scientific conclusion is used as the premise from which impossible-to-test deductions are drawn, and then these empirically unverifiable deductions are presented to the nonscientist public as certain scientific knowledge, the validity of which everyone who is not an intellectual troglodyte is obligated to accept and believe. The inescapable logical fact, however, is that no such deduction can be more certain than the uncertain scientific conclusion it is based on. Nevertheless, theoretical scientists have, with considerable success, propagandized and proselytized this illogical heretical scientific practice to the nonscientist public as standard procedure.
Scientifically, this disingenuous practice, this "Don't call scientific conclusions truth, but go ahead and treat them as truth anyway" practice has the cost of causing scientists to ignore the inescapable fact that scientific knowledge is a work in progress, and it always will be. Scientists must never close their minds to the possibility that even our most securely established scientific knowledge may be wrong, and might be improved if we made the effort. But more importantly, I am concerned that this practice of passing theoretical speculations off to the public as scientific knowledge may be partly responsible for the obstinate refusal of many nonscientists in the United States to accept and act upon scientific knowledge which is empirically well supported, scientific knowledge which has the well established ability to reliably improve human existence.
The purpose of this essay is to try to inform the scientifically skeptical nonscientist of the difference between such unreliable and untrustworthy theoretical science excesses and reliable scientific knowledge. Though not in this order, it will: Illustrate how theoreticians treat scientific knowledge as truth; Explain why scientific knowledge is not truth; Explain what scientific knowledge really is; Show why it is enormously successful, reliable and useful even though it is not truth; Point out how the presumption of scientific truth is itself destructive of scientific knowledge; and finally, Note the implications of all of this for theoretical and practical science issues.

GENRE
Nonfiction
RELEASED
2014
November 7
LANGUAGE
EN
English
LENGTH
163
Pages
PUBLISHER
Donald R. Miklich
SELLER
Draft2Digital, LLC
SIZE
192.1
KB

More Books Like This

Philosophy of Science: A Very Short Introduction Philosophy of Science: A Very Short Introduction
2002
The Art of Philosophizing The Art of Philosophizing
2014
The Magic of Consciousness The Magic of Consciousness
2012
Mysticism and Logic and Other Essays Mysticism and Logic and Other Essays
2011
Mind and Cosmos Mind and Cosmos
2012
Works of Charles Sanders Peirce Works of Charles Sanders Peirce
2013

More Books by Donald R. Miklich

1001 Sex Positions 1001 Sex Positions
2017
Deliberately Dumb: Understanding America's Education Failure Deliberately Dumb: Understanding America's Education Failure
2015
Objective Reality Objective Reality
2020
Galileo's Balls: Did He Really Drop Them? Galileo's Balls: Did He Really Drop Them?
2015

Customers Also Bought

Free Will: An Examination of Human Freedom Free Will: An Examination of Human Freedom
2012
Critical Thinking Unleashed: How To Improve And Refine Your Thinking Process To Think More Effectively Critical Thinking Unleashed: How To Improve And Refine Your Thinking Process To Think More Effectively
2020
Critical Thinking Series #1: Basic Skills 1 -Critical Thinking and Research Critical Thinking Series #1: Basic Skills 1 -Critical Thinking and Research
2016
The Problems of Philosophy The Problems of Philosophy
2009
Theory of Thought Theory of Thought
2014
Invisible Prisons of the Human Mind Invisible Prisons of the Human Mind
2016