The Production of Security

The introduction to this stunning work is by Murray Rothbard, who calls French radical Gustave de Molinari (1819–1912) the great innovator in the market provision of security. Indeed, he might be regarded as the first proponent of what is called anarchocapitalism.

Molinari was steeped in the old liberal worldview of Bastiat, dedicated to private property and free markets. But Molinari took matters further. In The Production of Security, he argues that markets are also better at providing the service that the state claimed was its monopoly privilege: the provision of security itself.

He goes toe to toe with the false assumption of Hobbes that somehow the state is necessary to keep society from devolving into chaos. On the contrary, argues Molinari, the voluntary society is ordered by freedom itself. There is no contradiction or even tension between liberty and security. If free enterprise works well in one sector, it can work well in other sectors.

Molinari was indeed a radical, but in the sense that foreshadowed the development of American libertarian thought: a radical for capitalism in all areas of life, a consistent champion of the fully free society.

Perhaps there was a time when people could regard the government monopoly on police and courts as benign, part of the "night-watchman" state advocated by the old-time classical liberals.

But the march of the police state has changed that. Our generation is more likely to understand that the state's "security" services are the gravest threat to liberty we face.

In that sense, Molinari is the man of the hour.