Christmas Baby Daddy

Finn: I'm good at making investments, making money, making profit. I'm not so good at making connections. While I've been with plenty of women since moving to New York City after college, I haven't found one that really intrigues me, makes me laugh, makes me think. So imagine my surprise when I decided to go home for Christmas and found my best friend's little sister all grown up. And boy, did she intrigue me. A little too much eggnog led to something forbidden between us, but when our families decided they hated each other over the secrets they're keeping, I figured nothing would come of that night. But when I come back home for the holidays this year, I realize I couldn't have been more wrong. It looks like our parents are the only ones keeping secrets. 

Abby: I've always thought he was hot, but he never gave me a second look. Not like I blamed him, I was a scrawny geek with glasses and braces. But this geek has become tres chic, and when he came home from Christmas last year, his head turned in my direction. One night of drunken passion had one little unexpected consequence: I ended up pregnant. But by the time I found out, he was long gone and our parents had made my brother and I vow not to talk to anyone in that family. That's why I'm shocked when he shows up at my massage therapy practice with a familiar look in his eye. But will he still look at me the same way when he finds out about our little Christmas present?